Capsular contracture is the most common reason people with breast implants need further surgery. Understanding what it is, how it is graded and what the options are can help you recognise it early and make calm, informed decisions.
What is a capsule?
Whenever an implant is placed in the body, the body forms a thin layer of scar tissue around it, called a capsule. This is normal and expected. In most people the capsule stays soft and thin, and the breast feels and looks natural.
What is capsular contracture?
In some people the capsule thickens and tightens, squeezing the implant. The breast can become firm, change shape, sit higher, look rounder or feel uncomfortable. Published reviews report a wide range of rates, roughly 3 to 20 percent of women within 5 to 10 years of breast augmentation, depending on the study, the implant and how contracture is defined.
How it is graded: the Baker scale
- Grade I: the breast is soft and looks natural.
- Grade II: the breast is a little firm but looks normal.
- Grade III: the breast is firm and looks abnormal, for example rounder or higher.
- Grade IV: the breast is hard, painful and visibly distorted.
Grades III and IV usually need treatment. Grades I and II are generally monitored.
Why does it happen?
The exact cause is not fully understood, and it is likely to involve several factors. A leading explanation is a low-grade bacterial film on the implant surface (biofilm) that keeps the surrounding tissue mildly inflamed over time. Bleeding around the implant, implant rupture, radiotherapy and smoking are also linked to a higher risk. Early contracture (within about six months) is more often related to factors at the time of surgery; later contracture is more often linked to biofilm.
Can the risk be reduced?
No technique removes the risk entirely. Careful measures at the time of surgery are designed to lower it: antibiotics at the start of the anaesthetic, minimising contact between the implant and the skin, meticulous control of bleeding, and choosing the implant and pocket to suit your tissues. Not smoking or vaping, before and after surgery, matters too. Implant surface also plays a role, and in Australia the TGA has suspended or cancelled most macro-textured implants because of their association with BIA-ALCL, a rare lymphoma; your implant choice is discussed in detail at consultation.
Signs to watch for
- a breast that becomes firmer, tighter or more rounded than before;
- a change in position, with one implant sitting higher;
- new discomfort or aching;
- a change in shape or symmetry you have not noticed before.
Any new swelling, lump or fluid collection more than a year after surgery should always be checked promptly, as it needs specific investigation.
How is it treated?
Treatment depends on the grade, your symptoms, your implant and your goals. Options include:
- Monitoring for mild, comfortable contracture.
- Capsulectomy with implant replacement: the capsule is removed and a new implant placed, sometimes in a different pocket.
- Implant removal with capsulectomy, with or without a breast lift (mastopexy) to reshape the breast.
Imaging such as ultrasound or MRI is often used beforehand to check the implant and capsule. Forcefully squeezing the breast to break the capsule (closed capsulotomy) is no longer recommended because it can rupture the implant. Contracture can recur after treatment, and this is discussed honestly before any decision. Learn more on our implant removal and capsulectomy page.
Frequently asked questions
Is capsular contracture dangerous?
It is not usually dangerous, but it can be uncomfortable and change the look of the breast. Severe contracture can contribute to implant rupture, so it should be assessed.
Do implants need to be replaced at a set time?
Implants are not lifetime devices. Many are removed or replaced within 10 to 15 years, but there is no automatic expiry date; decisions are based on symptoms, examination and imaging.
Can massage or medicines fix it?
There is no proven non-surgical cure for established contracture. Some treatments are being researched, but surgery remains the standard treatment for symptomatic grades III and IV.
Will it happen again after surgery?
It can. Careful technique lowers the risk, but recurrence is possible and is part of the consent discussion.
This article is general information, not personal medical advice. All surgery carries risks; please read our surgical risks page. In Australia a GP referral and at least two consultations are required before cosmetic surgery.
If your implants have changed, start with your GP, then book a consultation with Dr Hatem Elfieshawy, a registered medical practitioner (general registration) with a field of practice in cosmetic surgery and medicine, FACCSM(Surg).
References
- Headon H, Kasem A, Mokbel K. Capsular contracture after breast augmentation: an update for clinical practice. Arch Plast Surg. 2015;42(5):532-43.
- Susini P, et al. Advances on capsular contracture: prevention and management strategies. PRS Global Open. 2023.
- RACGP. Breast implants: a guide for general practice. AJGP 2021.
- Therapeutic Goods Administration. Breast implant hub.